Wednesday, August 1, 2012

Liverpool Need More than Dempsey to Replace Carroll


News that Liverpool had accepted a £2mil loan offer from West Ham United for Andy Carroll – with a view to a £17mil permanent move should the Hammers stay up – was widely met with disappointment but not shock by Liverpool fans.

The England striker had finally started to hit top form towards the end of the season, with important goals against Blackburn Rovers, Everton and Chelsea. He followed up those impressive performances with a ruthless header against Sweden in the European Championships in a 3-2 win.

The appointment of Brendan Rodgers as Liverpool manager at the beginning of June meant that the Reds would be playing an attractive brand of football based around possession this coming season. Alarm bells began ringing immediately for Liverpool fans regarding the future of Carroll at the club. The worry is that Carroll will struggle to adapt to a more possession-oriented style of play, but at the same time fingers can be pointed at Danny Graham, who played a similar role to great effect for Rodgers’ old side Swansea last season.

Still, it is looking extremely likely that Carroll will be moved on this summer. With West Ham already having a bid accepted and Carroll’s hometown club Newcastle waiting in the wings, it seems only a matter of time until the target man is shown the door. The most recent hint is that despite being named in the squad, Carroll has not travelled with the team for their opening Europa League qualifier in Belarus against FC Gomel, supposedly due to injury.

This inevitable transaction leaves a gaping hole in Liverpool’s forward line. Throughout the summer transfer window the Reds have been linked with Fulham forward Clint Dempsey. The American has just come off his most successful season in England, scoring 17 goals in 37 league games, with 23 goals in 46 appearances in all competitions.

At 29 he does not fit the FSG (Fenway Sports Group) transfer model of buying young players with high re-sale value and developing them into top players. Despite this disparity with FSG policy, Dempsey had a fantastic season for Fulham and deserves recognition for that. He is a versatile attacker that can play anywhere across the front line and even in midfield if needed. He is good technically and always manages to find himself in the right place at the right time to score – something which Liverpool glaringly lacked last season. His main flaw is his decision making, often times choosing to shoot when he should pass and pass when he should shoot. He can be very selfish on the ball, and takes an eternity to release the ball at times.

Dempsey’s Fulham form is in stark contrast to his performances for the US national team, where he seems to miss open goals for fun. He still manages to get himself on the score sheet relatively often, but considering the chances he gets on a silver platter, he should be scoring much more.

There is no doubt that Dempsey can add something to the Liverpool squad, but is a late bloomer who has had one top class season really enough to replace a 23-year-old who is just re-discovering his monstrous form from his pre-Liverpool days?

If the signing of Dempsey and the departure of Carroll do transpire, that leaves Liverpool with Luis Suarez, Fabio Borini, Dempsey and the possibly Cardiff-bound Craig Bellamy as their only first-team striking options. For a team that is going to be challenging on four fronts in the 2012-2013 season, this shows an abysmal lack of depth – something which has haunted Liverpool consistently over the last decade.

Rodgers will need to take a good look at his squad and realize the need for at least one other striker and hopefully a pacey winger, especially if Bellamy returns home to Wales.

Liverpool have been linked with a number of strikers this transfer window, with the likes of Chelsea’s Daniel Sturridge and Fiorentina’s Stevan Jovetic causing the most excitement amongst fans, despite being a touch unrealistic.

In terms of wingers, one name never seems to go away, which is that of Uruguayan 21-year-old Gaston Ramirez. The Bologna attacker has been linked with Liverpool since the January transfer window and the rumors have not died down since the sacking of Kenny Dalglish. He has most recently been impressing in the Olympics for the Uruguayan national team, scoring a stunning free-kick against the United Arab Emirates in their opening game at Old Trafford.

Other wingers rumored to be on their way to Anfield include Swansea winger Scott Sinclair, Barcelona youngster Gerard Deulofeu and Arsenal’s Theo Walcott.

Most Liverpool fans have accepted that the departure of Carroll will happen this summer, and it is important for Rodgers to recognize that the signing of Dempsey as a direct replacement will not be enough. With Liverpool playing in Europe yet again this season, depth is required. Rodgers will have to assess and adjust accordingly if he hopes to have a successful first season on Merseyside.

No comments:

Post a Comment